Sugar plant reduces water consumption without compromising reliability
Key Highlights
- Four continuously operating pumps saved more than 6.2 million liters of water over a 180-day production season.
- Water use per converted application fell by approximately 80%, from 8–12 liters per minute to 1–2 liters per minute.
- Seal service life increased from an average of three to four months to several years, with no reported failures since 2019.
Manufacturers around the world face a growing challenge. Water resources are tightening, regulatory pressure is increasing, and production demands show no sign of slowing down. Many facilities assume that reducing water consumption means accepting some tradeoff in output or reliability. A recent project at a German sugar producer tells a different story, one where a targeted equipment upgrade delivered major water savings while improving reliability and reducing maintenance burden.
The results are striking. Water use for mechanical seal cooling and lubrication dropped by approximately 80% across four continuously operating pumps. Over a full six-month production season, that reduction equated to savings of more than 6.2 million liters. For an industry where water resilience increasingly determines long-term viability, this project offers a practical blueprint worth examining closely.
The problem behind the numbers
Sugar processing runs on seasonal campaigns, periods when the crop is processed around the clock for months at a stretch. Equipment reliability during these windows isn't optional. A failure mid-campaign can ripple through an entire production schedule. Before the retrofit, this particular facility struggled with seals failing every three to four months. High heat generation, poor lubrication, and abrasive, crystallizing process media combined to create a punishing operating environment. Several applications also relied on heavy water volumes just to keep seals cool and properly lubricated, water that was being consumed far faster than necessary.
The customer had two clear goals: extend mean time between repair and cut water consumption. Those goals aren't always easy to pursue simultaneously, since aggressive cooling strategies often rely on high water flow as a simple, if wasteful, solution. Solving for both required a more precise engineering approach.
Matching the seal to the application
Four pump applications were involved in this program, covering thin juice, thick juice, and recirculation or distillation process streams. Operating conditions varied considerably, ranging from 80 to 133 degrees Celsius and 1 to 4 bar, with pumps running at 960 rpm. No single seal design could address all four applications effectively. Each one demanded a configuration suited to its specific process conditions, existing pump design, and seal support arrangement.
John Crane engineers began by measuring the available installation space on each pump. From there, Type 587, Type 5620, and SB2 Upstream Pumping seal configurations were selected based on fit and performance requirements. The solution set included both 65 mm and 95 mm SB2 USP designs, supported where appropriate by API Plan 52 or John Crane SafeUnit SFD barrier fluid systems. Importantly, this approach allowed the existing pumps to remain in place. No major equipment replacement was required, which kept the retrofit practical and cost effective for the customer.
Planning and preparation for the first conversions took close to a year. Conversions then began progressively, starting roughly seven years ago, allowing the customer to validate performance on a smaller scale before expanding the program across all four applications. That patient, phased approach proved important. It gave the customer confidence in the technology before committing further.
The results in practice
Water use on each converted application fell from 8 to 12 liters per minute down to approximately 1 to 2 liters per minute. Across all four pumps, that translates to a calculated saving of at least 34,560 liters every 24 hours, and more than 240,000 liters over a single week. With all four pumps running continuously through a 180-day campaign, total savings exceeded 6.2 million liters.
The reliability improvement proved just as significant as the water savings. Since 2019, the four converted applications have operated without a single reported seal failure. Seal service life increased from a previous average of three to four months to several years. For a facility that had grown accustomed to frequent, disruptive seal replacements, this shift represents a fundamental change in how maintenance planning and resource allocation can be approached.
Why this matters beyond sugar processing
This case illustrates a broader principle that applies across water intensive industries, from food and beverage processing to pulp and paper, chemical manufacturing, and beyond. Water use tied to mechanical seal cooling and lubrication is often treated as a fixed cost of doing business, an unavoidable consequence of keeping rotating equipment running. That assumption deserves scrutiny.
Precision engineered seal configurations, properly matched to actual process conditions rather than generic specifications, can dramatically reduce water consumption without compromising performance. In many cases, as this example shows, the opposite occurs. Reliability improves alongside efficiency gains, since better seal design reduces the heat, friction, and media exposure that cause premature failure in the first place.
For manufacturers facing increasing scrutiny over water use, whether from regulators, local communities, or internal sustainability targets, this is an encouraging signal. Meaningful water savings don't necessarily require production slowdowns or expensive full equipment replacements. Sometimes the answer lies in re-engineering a single, often overlooked component.
Looking ahead
The customer in this case is already planning further conversions, extending the same approach to additional applications across the facility. That kind of expansion speaks to the confidence built through measured, phased implementation and clearly documented results.
As water resources face mounting pressure worldwide, manufacturers will continue searching for practical paths to reduce consumption while protecting production output. This project demonstrates that those two goals are not in conflict. With the right engineering approach, targeted upgrades to existing equipment can deliver substantial water savings, strengthen reliability, and reduce maintenance demands all at once. For an industry under growing pressure to do more with less, that combination may prove to be exactly the model worth replicating.
About the Author
Aziz Sallie
Vice President, Global Accounts/Turbo Machinery & Service Solutions, John Crane
Aziz Sallie is vice president of global accounts, turbo machinery & service solutions at John Crane.
Related
At Eurial’s Quincampoix dairy in Normandy, a single Qdos CWT (Conveying Wave Technology) dosing pump now treats the 300m3 of water needed to feed the entire plant daily after it replaced a diaphragm pump.
john_crane_image_3232026

